Each week, we cover your favorite dark and creepy stories, and pick apart the weird science and history behind them. True Crime/Science/History/Comedy Podcast. Hosted by Kimberly Baker, Lila Dunk, and Allyson Nemec.
Check us out on your preferred platform below, and consider subscribing to Twitter and Instagram for more up to date content.
Today is a special day, because we’re hopping in the time
machine back to the turn of the century in America, for a good old
fashioned historical murder! It’s been some time since we really
dug deep into the dark history of this country, and I was super
interested in this case as I did more research into it, as it has
everything. It’s a tale of murder, of dark family secrets, town
gossip, and finally, an execution which was screwed up so badly
that it completely changed the way the death penalty was handled in
the entire state. This is the story of Roxana Druse, a middle aged
woman who, after decades of abuse from her husband, snapped and
killed him, with the help of her whole family. Roxana, also known
as Roxy, and also known as Roxalana, was the last woman to be
hanged in New York State, and the shit job that was done during her
hanging, which we’ll get into later, was a major part in New York
State’s replacement of the gallows with the far more humane and
“user friendly” execution method; the electric chair. Now, before
we get into the story, I want to thank listener Marion Dunk for the
recommendation on this topic! And you may say, hey, Dunk, that last
name sounds familiar! Well that’s because this topic recommendation
comes courtesy of Lila’s Mom herself! Thanks Momma Dunk! And also,
I want to try to get through our backlog of listener recommended
topics, so if you have a story or topic you want us to do an
episode on, please reach out to us on social media, or by emailing
us at DeathDamesPodcast@gmail.com! But with that, let’s get into
the marriage, and abrupt end to the marriage, of Roxy and William
Druse.
Now, we’re talking mid 1800's at the point of the couple’s
marriage, so unfortunately, little is known about the pair before
their blessed union. We do know that prior to her marriage, Roxy
lived and worked in New Hartford, New York, where she was employed
at a Mill. She was a perfectly normal girl, with no history of
violence that was ever reported, at least. As for her husband
William, well I know less about him. However, at the time the
couple was married, Roxy was in her late teens, and William was
around 20 years older than her, in his late 30's, early 40's. I do
wish I had exact timelines for these things, but this was around
1860, so they didn’t have a Facebook I could look up. The newly
married couple moved from New Hartford, NY, to a small, dirty,
yellow farmhouse in Herkimer, NY, where the pair intended to work
the farm to make a living together. The pair soon grew pregnant,
and their first daughter Mary, was born around 1865. To follow Mary
was born a son, named George, born 9 years after Mary. There was
also another child born of Roxy and William, but the child died
around 1872. At the time of the child’s death, the people of
Herkimer were suspicious, and rumors began to circulate that Mrs.
Druse had had something to do with the tragedy. However, no
investigation was launched into the death, so life resumed as
normal for the family. Now, unfortunately, normal life for the
Druse family was anything but normal, as tensions were constantly
on high in the home. William was known throughout town for being a
lazy farmer, and was considered useless by many, as he gave up
fairly quickly on properly tending to their land, which therefore
meant that the family barely made enough money to scrape by. It was
also well known that William was a violent man, who would often
scream and abuse his family when his short fuse would blow, and
that Roxy and William were always at odds with one another.
Neighbors would constantly complain of the couple, who would get
into screaming matches at all hours of the day and night. And as
for Roxy, despite the fact that William was pretty disinterested in
making a comfortable living for the family, she was not allowed to
leave the farmhouse to seek work, as William had purposely chosen
to keep his wife in the farmhouse, rarely letting her leave for
trips to see family, or to do the shopping. He wanted her kept
locked in their home, at his beck and call. This, as we have seen
before, is a telltale mark of an abuser, and it was well known that
William was frequently verbally and physically abusive to his wife.
Looking for more help on the farm, however, Roxy was able to
convince William to hire on a nephew, Frank Gates, to work on the
farm in exchange for room and board. Frank agreed, and thus one
more family member was crammed into the small farmhouse.
By 1884, tensions had risen to catastrophic levels. Roxy, at
this point a tired old woman of 37, had grown exhausted by her
marriage of around 20 years to the violent William, who was, at
this point, 60 years old. They lived in the home with their
daughter Mary, who was 18 or 19 (different sources say different
things), their son George, who was 10, and their nephew Frank, who
was 14. And by December of 1884, William would disappear completely
from the house. By December 16th, people around town began to
notice that William was missing from his usual spots at the local
bar. It didn’t take long for a theory to form, but ironically,
people of the town who had noticed Williams disappearance were
worried that William had actually gone mad and murdered his whole
family, and then skipped town. They were close, of course. But not
quite right. By the 18th, concerned citizens made their way to the
old townhouse, hoping to find out what had happened to the Druse
family. When there, the visitors were greeted by the sight of thick
black smoke billowing from the chimney, and a horrible, acrid
smell, like that of charred meat. The odor was stifling, and the
people visiting the home had to cover their faces to breath. The
door to the house was locked, which, at the time, was extremely
odd. When they tried to peek into the windows for any sign of life,
they were startled to see that all the windows of the house had
been completely covered with newspaper, making any line of sight
within the home completely impossible. Rumors began to spread, and
it didn’t take long for Roxy herself to show up in town, acting as
if nothing was amiss. Roxy, when asked about her husband’s
disappearance, simply shrugged it off, saying that William had
simply unexpectedly left to visit her brother in New York City, who
worked as a grocer. He had needed some help, and apparently,
William, the lazy asshole who didn’t even like to work on his own
land, had volunteered to help out. Roxy also claimed that she had
even sent out several telegraphs to find out when he would be
coming home, but never heard back from him. People began to put
pressure on the police, suggesting that something had happened to
William, and that Roxy had done it. Whenever Roxy heard whispers of
the murder of her husband, she would apparently go into a wild
rage, and tell who ever had spread the rumor that she would sue
them for slander, and that she would sue anyone who repeated the
story that she had killed her husband. Super normal reaction,
there, Rox. Smooth.
Unsurprisingly, it didn’t take long for police, receiving tips
and concerns from multiple citizens and neighbors, began to take
notice of William’s disappearance. In fact, the neighbors on either
side of the Druse home, Charles Pett to the west and the Eckler
family to the east, had both begun their own investigations. The
two families firmly believed that William had met with foul play,
and were the first to notice the black smoke on the 18th. Both Mr.
Eckler and Charles Pett decided that the answer would lie with the
children. Naturally, this is before we had those silly things like
rights for children, so the two grown men, over the course of
several days, interrogated the children of the house, but
specifically, Frank, the 14 year old nephew of Roxy, who was, they
believed, the weakest link in the family. Eventually, Frank, afraid
of the pressure he was receiving, cracked, and told Pett and Eckler
that he was ready to tell his story. The police were called, and
District Attorney A.B Steele arrived, ready to put the squeeze to a
14 year old boy, placed Frank under arrest.
And this is around the point where I start to have doubts about
literally everything. Frank was placed under police arrest, and was
aggressively questioned by police. Now, I’m going to say this
again. Frank was 14. He was living away from his parents, away from
siblings, friends, he was living with an abusive family member in a
small town where he didn’t really know anyone. And now he was under
arrest, and being questioned by police about his Uncle’s murder.
And after several hours of intense questioning, Frank told a story.
So we’re going to do something a little different than usual. When
I was looking through my research, I found Frank’s actual words
recorded in his confession, so instead of paraphrasing, I’m going
to read his words directly. This was the story that Frank told
police about the murder of William Druse.
“My name is Frank Gates. I live in Warren. I have
lived for the past five or six weeks with my aunt Mrs. William
Druse. I did chores for my board and went to school. My uncle
was killed the Thursday before Christmas. I helped to kill
him and depose of the remains. Last summer my aunt wanted to
hire me to shoot Uncle William. She said she would give me a
good many dollars for doing it. I told her I would not do
it. There was nothing more said then, but this winter my aunt
and Uncle Bill had a good many words. On Thursday before Christmas
in the morning, Uncle Bill asked me to get up and build the
fire. I did so. Aunt Roxy and Mary, her daughter, got
up. Uncle Bill went and did the chores. I asked if I
should help him, and he said 'No.' He said he would rather do
them himself. When he came into his breakfast he sat down to
the table. I had nearly finished mine. My aunt told me
to hurry up. I asked her what she wanted. She then told
me and George to go out of doors, but not to go far from the house.
I heard a noise three or four times. Then she called
us. She had a revolver. She handed it to me and told me
to shoot Uncle Bill or she would shoot me. She put the
revolver up to my nose when she said this. I then fired at
Uncle William. He was sitting in a chair or on the
floor. I was so excited I could not say which. Then she
took the revolver and fired at him until the revolver was empty.
Then she took the axe and pounded him on the head. Uncle Bill
said 'Oh Roxy, don't.' She then chopped his head off and sent me
and George upstairs after a straw tick which was filled. She
dragged him onto the tick and told me I should help drag him into
the parlor... She built up a hot fire in both stoves, and then had
me watch at the north window and Mary watch at the south
window. Then she took a block and a board into the parlor and
chopped him up, and then put the pieces in the fire. She told
me to crowd the kitchen stove with shingles. Next day all I saw of
him was a large bone. Mary had that and put it in the other
stove. It had flesh on each end. Next morning she took
up the ashes from the stoves, put some in a bag and some in a tin
box. She told me to hitch up the horse, as she was going to
my father's... I took the ashes and threw them on the ground.
We then went to father's, and I was taken sick and had to stay home
a few days... When we were on our way back she threw the ax into
the pond as we passed over the bridge. There was a newspaper
wrapped around the ax... She said I must do it or I would be
sorry."
From this point in his confession, Frank went on to implicate
everyone else in the house, claiming that 18 year old Mary was
present when William was first shot by Roxy, and that Mary actually
held him in place with a rope while Roxy shot him. Of George, Frank
claimed that the 10 year old boy seemed completely unaffected by
the violent crime which took place, and that, while Roxy
dismembered the corpse of her husband, George gleefully sat in an
adjacent room, playing checkers. He also began to escalate the
story with each retelling, soon claiming that Roxy boiled the body
and fed the flesh to their pigs, and that the head was cooked in
the oven. There was no outright mention of cannibalism, but it was
heavily implied. But this story was definitely enough for police to
move forward with a case against Roxy, so the whole family was
arrested, including George and Mary. Using Frank’s confession,
police attempted to find proof of the crime, and to find the
remains of William Druse. Police did eventually find a frozen lump
of bone and ash. It consisted of about 18 to 20 tony pieces of
bone, two knee caps, and the upper end of the left tibia. Although
it was not much, the coroner seemed sure enough that it was human.
Of course, this is before DNA, but the coroner was sure that it was
William. Near the remains, the paper wrapped ax was also found
where Frank claimed he had thrown it. At this point, the case was
heating up. The police set up an inquest on January 17th, to find
out exactly what had happened, in Roxana’s words.
At the official inquest, police brought in several neighbors
and local friends of the family to testify about the black smoke,
about the tumultuous relationship between the couple. Some
mentioned that after William’s disappearance, they went to visit
the Druse home and noticed that all the wooden surfaces in the
kitchen had been repainted recently. Frank was again put on the
stand and he repeated his elaborate story. When George was placed
on the stand, however, he had something a little different to say.
George did say that most of what Frank had said was true, but he
had omitted one detail that was crucially important. Frank’s
father, Roxana’s brother, was also there. According to George, his
uncle, Charley Gates, was actually the one who originally handed
the revolver to Roxy, and that the murder was all his idea. After
everyone else had spoken, the main event was sworn in. Roxana Druse
sat on the stand.
Now, once Roxy was in custody, she was not particularly
interested in being involved in the entire process. When she was
questioned, she answered honestly, however, but when asked if
anyone was present at the time of her husband’s death, Roxy replied
that yes, there were two others there. Frank Gates, and his father,
Charles. Once stating this, Roxy refused to give any additional
information, afraid of incriminating her children in error. She
did, however, say that it was Charles, who had fired several shots
into William’s body, while she did as well. And that he was the
mastermind behind the murder. Also, she stated that Gates was there
throughout the whole process of disposing of the corpse, and that
he helped with the burning process as well. When asked about her
marriage, Roxy explained that her husband was not a good man. In
fact, she specifically stated that the only time in their marriage
that William treated her kindly was on their wedding day. Almost
immediately into the marriage, his darkness began to show. When
asked what would happen if she was found guilty, Roxy flippantly
responded that whether she was sentenced to life in prison or
hanging, she would never have to live with the abuse from William
Druse again. When she was placed in her jail cell, she said, quote,
“Well, I hope I may be able to procure tonight what I have not had
before in two years, a good night’s rest.”
The official trial of Roxana Druse began on September 24th,
1885, and would go on to last two weeks. Not much changed from the
formal inquest, other than the fact that some of the kitchen
floorboards had been pried up and they were coated with blood. Roxy
never took the stand herself, but her defense team attempted to
claim that she had taken her husband’s life in self dense, after
two long decades of abuse. Regardless, with the evidence placed
forward by Frank, and the brutality of the murder and disposal of
the body that he had described, their defense had no chance. Roxana
was found guilty of murder in the first degree when the Jury agreed
unanimously. The courtroom was filled with visitors from all over
New York, desperate to see the outcome of one of the most vicious
crimes perpetrated by a woman in many years. Roxana, when she heard
the finding of guilty, grew pale but showed no emotion. However
Mary, upon hearing her mother’s fate, began to weep loudly and
openly. The judge stated that, due to the fact that she had caused
her husband’s death, in front of his children, the way she had
dismembered his remains, the jury had been shocked and appalled by
her acts. They seemed most upset, ironically, by the inclusion of
George, her 10 year old son. She was then brought in several days
later to learn her sentence. The judge asked her to rise while he
stated that she will be hung by the neck until dead. She was to be
executed on November 24th, 1885, just a few weeks after her
sentencing. Roxana again showed no emotion when she learned of her
fate, but when she was removed from the courtroom, she burst into
tears, covering her face while her body shook with sobs. No woman
had been executed in this area of New York for over 40 years, so
everyone was in shock that Roxana would be executed.
[Pictured: Roxy in her cell Photo
Credit: murderpedia.org]
After the trial of Roxana Druse, the family was not done yet.
Mary Druse, the daughter of Roxy and William, was found guilty of
murder in the second degree and sentenced to life in prison. George
and Frank were both released, and as for Charles Gates, he was
never arrested for his involvement, despite the fact that Mary,
George, and Roxy all stated he was present. His involvement was
never investigated. Many people of New York and beyond were not
happy with how this trial had gone, and there was an influx of
pleas and requests from women’s rights activists, and clergymen
from all of the country. The requests were to either push the
execution of Roxana, or, more likely to remove the sentence of
execution and instead give her life in prison, due to the
circumstances of the murder. Many claimed that, since she had been
a long time sufferer of domestic abuse, that it was unfair to
condemn her to death. Also, there was the fact that her jury
consisted of exclusively male jurors, therefore she had not been
tried by a jury of her peers, as is required by law. Her execution
date was eventually pushed until February 28th, 1887, and the local
government even considered changing the laws regarding capital
punishment in special cases, such as when the accused was a victim
of abuse, as in this case, but regardless, after a lengthy appeal
process, the Governor in charge of her case refused to alter her
sentence, and instead, stated that he would see her hang for her
crime.
[Pictured: Recreation of a news
article. Photo Credit: UnknownMisandry.blogspot.com]
The day before her execution, Roxana Druse made a confession to
her spiritual adviser, a man named Dr. Powell. During this
confession, she told him, once more, that Charles Gates was the one
responsible for William Druses’ death, and that he was present and
aided her in the murder. She confessed to having shot William once,
and then claimed that Charles took his own gun out shot three times
into William’s body. She did confess to chopping up his body, but
that Charles had been the one to burn it. She also requested a
chance to clear her daughter’s name, so Roxy wrote an affidavit
which stated that Mary Druse had nothing to do with the murder or
disposition of his body. She stayed up late the night before, but
eventually slept only a few hours before waking up with a scream.
She was calmed down by the staff, and then, instead of sleeping,
Roxy spent the time writing letters, thanking the sheriff for his
family’s kindness, requesting her body be sent to the pastor for
her burial. She wrote farewell letters to her children. She then
laid down for a bit more sleep until she was collected from her
cell at nine o clock in the morning. Dr. Powell returned to walk
with her to the gallows, and the two of them followed Sheriff Cook
and Under Sheriff Rice from the jail to the gallows. Roxana was
dressed in all black. It was an extremely cold morning, so the
sheriff’s wife lent Roxana a shawl to drape over her shoulders. In
front of a crowd of twenty five, Roxana stood firm until her eyes
caught the noose, and her body gave an involuntary tremor. She
began to cry when she knelt down below the rope, and entered a
prayer with Dr. Powell. Roxana tightly clutched a bouquet in her
hand, given to her by her daughter Mary, who she never got to say
goodbye to. When asked her final words, Roxana said that she wanted
to thank all who were kind to her during her trial and her time in
prison, and that she forgive those who spoke against her. The noose
was wrapped around her neck, and Roxana began to scream and cry
when the black hood was placed over her face. At 11:48 am the trap
sprung. Her neck did not break, due to a major mess up by the
creators of the gallows. There was not enough weight in the
counterweight used to accurately snap her neck. Her body shook and
convulsed for several minutes, until it grew still. Roxana Druse
took fifteen minutes until she was confirmed dead by strangulation.
Her body was left on the noose a total of twenty six minutes, until
she was cut down. Her body was placed in a rosewood coffin, and her
remains were taken to the Oak Hill cemetery.
[Pictured: Artist rendition of the
execution of Roxy Druse. Photo Credit: murderpedia.org]
Now, this is rough for sure, but there was some good which came
from this. Due to her deathbed confession, Roxana had assisted in
getting her daughter, Mary, cleared of all charges. Mary was
pardoned of her relation to the murder of her father, and she was
released after serving 10 years of her life sentence. She was taken
in by a friend of the family, a woman named Mrs. Sherman, who had
been a major player in getting Mary pardoned of the crime. While in
prison, Mary had been a model prisoner, and had helped to fix up
the garden in the woman’s prison. One other beneficial thing which
came from Roxana’s death was that, due to the way that her
execution was botched, she would be the last woman hanged in New
York State. Her execution was instrumental in replacing the use of
the gallows in New York with the much more “humane” execution
method of the electric chair. Also, there was an introduction of
the Hadley Bill in the NY State Assembly, which suggested that
capital punishment for women found guilty of first degree murder
should be abolished, as, at the time, women were unable to vote or
serve on a jury, therefore it was unconstitutional to have them
receive capital punishment. Despite all this, however, the case of
Roxana Druse has been a controversial one for decades, and many
believe that an innocent woman was hanged that cold February day in
1887. The fact that Charles Gates was never investigated for his
connection in the murder showed that there was a lack of interest
in finding additional information pertaining to this crime, and
that the testimony of a terrified 14 year old was used as the main
source of evidence in this case, which ended up solidifying a
woman’s execution, showed the police at the time took the statement
of a teenager boy as carrying more weight than that of two grown
women. Regardless of your thoughts on this, however, one thing we
do know is that even in death, Roxana still has left her mark on
the world, literally. It is said that, in the cell she had lived
prior to her death, the ghost of Roxana Druse haunts the halls,
moaning and murmuring, the black cap still over her face.
Each week, we cover your favorite dark and creepy stories, and pick apart the weird science and history behind them. True Crime/Science/History/Comedy Podcast.
Hosted by Kimberly Baker, Lila Dunk, and Allyson Nemec.